Fresh Seafood Dining
Freshly prepared seafood dishes including fish tacos, salmon burgers, and signature crab cakes.
- Panko-breaded preparations available
- Custom cooking preferences accommodated
- Indoor and outdoor seating
⭐ 3.9 (88 reviews)
Visibility: 53/100Reel Kitchen operates as both a casual seafood restaurant and fresh fish market, known for exceptionally fresh seafood including standout crab cakes and Alaskan king crab. Customers consistently praise the passionate owner-operator who remembers regular orders, though opinions vary on value and preparation consistency. The restaurant attracts locals seeking fresh, healthy seafood options in a clean, friendly environment.
Based on 88 customer reviews
Address: 112 Main St, Kings Park, NY 11754, USA
Phone: (631) 460-4175
Parking: Strip mall parking lot with ample free spaces
Peak times: Lunch hours 12pm-2pm and Friday evenings 6-8pm
Nearby neighborhoods: Commack, Smithtown, Fort Salonga
Nearby landmarks: Between local bakery and liquor store, Near Kings Park Bluff, Close to Sunken Meadow State Park
Freshly prepared seafood dishes including fish tacos, salmon burgers, and signature crab cakes.
Fresh seafood available for purchase to take home and prepare yourself.
Signature items like lobster mac and cheese and gourmet fish and chips.
Fresh sushi options complementing the cooked seafood menu.
⭐ 3.9 out of 5
88 total reviews
Rating steady at 3.9 stars over past 6 months. Mixed feedback on value but consistent praise for freshness.
“So happy with my first visit to Reel! Owner was super friendly. Remembered I wanted my Lobster Mac crust and he nailed it.the place is super clean. Can anyone say Valentines dinner?”
— Nancy“If this place was on the water in an upscale area, it would be known as the place to be. Unfortunately, Reel Kitchen is located between a bakery and a liquor store on a strip mall. But, as many foodies will tell you, some of the best restaurants are crammed in small shopping centers. As someone whose diet consists of mostly seafood, I have been fortunate enough to eat at a lot of restaurants and seafood markets throughout the country. I can say that the crabcake from Reel Kitchen was hands-down the best I have ever had and the salmon burger was cooked to absolute perfection and fulfilled every bit of the craving I had. The owner was extremely friendly and seems to put his true heart and passion into the cooking. I urge anyone that enjoys seafood to check this place out…you will not be disappointed.”
— Thomas Helou“Great little local place for fresh fish. Lots of good healthy choices we got tacos they were deep fried that scared me but they weren't totally greasy except for the outside. The fish wasn't soaked in it. We sat outside nice spot to relax. I like local people like this work hard in our community and we need to support them. I can find cheaper maybe I guess seems like it. Friendly staff good customer service”
— KENNETH ASH“I love this little hidden gem! The seafood is so fresh! You can buy anything fresh or have it cooked. the Alaskan King Crab is insanely good ! ❗️must try The baked salmon it’s s my go-to—it’s breaded with Panko so it’s nice and light. The fish and chips are also really good they use old bays seasoning on the fries so they’re packed with flavor. I’m going with a 4 because I usually judge a seafood place on their chowder and it’s not that this chowder is bad I just prefer a creamier clam chowder and this is more watery than I’d like. They also have a really nice sushi selection. Service is great everyone is super friendly. There’s a couple indoor tables but I normally do take out.”
— Marissa AndersonYes, we operate as both a restaurant and fish market with daily fresh selections available for purchase.
Our crab cakes and Alaskan King Crab are customer favorites, along with our panko-crusted salmon preparations.
Absolutely! Our owner-chef accommodates preferences like extra crust on dishes and custom preparations.
Yes, we have outdoor seating that customers enjoy for a relaxing dining experience.
Yes, we offer a selection of fresh sushi alongside our cooked seafood menu items.
Status: Open now
Peak hours: Lunch 12-2pm
Fresh fish delivery: Daily morning arrivals
Popular this week: Crab cakes, King crab, Salmon
⭐ 4.4 (893) · 3.6 miles
215 West Main Street, Smithtown
⭐ 4.3 (1277) · 3.3 miles
2159 Jericho Turnpike, Commack
⭐ 4.2 (90) · 0.2 miles
56 Main Street, Kings Park
⭐ 4.3 (382) · 3.6 miles
175 West Main Street, Smithtown
⭐ 3.5 (67) · 3.6 miles
402 Larkfield Road, East Northport
⭐ 3.7 (17) · 3.8 miles
220 Laurel Road, East Northport
How easily local customers can find and choose this business online.
This business profile is managed with Buzza AI on Clover.
REEL KITCHEN INC. manages this profile with Buzza AI on Clover. Business owner? Manage your listing from your Clover Dashboard.
REEL KITCHEN INC. is part of the Buzza local business network.
Browse more restaurants & food on Buzza →